"IndoorGameBunker is supported by its readers. Please assume all links are affiliate links. If you purchase something from one of our links we make a small commission from Amazon."

Top 5 Best Magnetic Card Sleeves

best magnetic card sleeves

Magnetic card sleeves are a great way to easily store your most valuable cards. They have a convenient magnetic closure system that makes it quick and easy to place and remove cards from. However, not all the magnetic card sleeves on the market are created equal.

Some have weak magnets, while others will show scratches easily. We sifted through the competition to find the best magnetic card sleeves for you to use on your trading cards. We judged our basis solely on the quality of the plastic, as well as the strength of the magnets.

In our comprehensive guide to the best magnetic card holders, we’ll show you the best card holders on the market and give you some advice when it comes time to choose. Let’s get started.

IN A HURRY? HERE’S OUR TOP PICKS…

NameOur RatingPrice

Ultra Pro 35-Point ONE-Touch Magnetic Trading Card Holder 
5/5
Click for Price
BCW Magnetic Card Holder4.5/5
Click for Price
Outus Magnetic Card Holder 35 Pt4/5
Click for Price

1- Ultra Pro 35-Point ONE-Touch Magnetic Trading Card Holder 

The first magnetic card sleeve on our list is the Ultra Pro 35-Point ONE-Touch Magnetic Trading Card Holder. Ultra Pro is the leader in the industry when it comes to protecting and storing your collectible cards. Their card sleeves are both durable and high quality.

Their magnetic card sleeves come in a pack of 5. They are made with non-PVC ultra clear materials which also helps with blocking sunlight. The size of these magnetic card holders is 35 pt which is the standard size for many trading cards like Pokemon, Yugioh, and sports cards.

At the top of the card holder is the magnetic closure that has a slide-in hinge that will help keep your card safe and secure.

What we like

  • High quality
  • UV resistant

What we don’t like

  • Some complaints that the holder is loose
  • Quality control/some customers had scratched cases arrive

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


2- BCW Magnetic Card Holder

The next brand on our list is the BCW Magnetic Card Holder. BCW is another great high quality brand that we really recommend. They have been creating high quality products for over 35 years and definitely prioritize quality and customer service.

These magnetic card sleeves come in a pack of 5 35 pt card holders for standard sized trading cards. It’s a simple two piece design with the magnetic closure at the top, similar to that of Ultra PRO. These card sleeves are very resistant to scratching which makes them a great choice for stacking on top of each other.

These card sleeves are easy to use and the magnet is very strong to allow for excellent protection. To open this sleeve simply use your fingernail or a quarter on the tab at the top of the card case. Once opened, simply place the card inside and replace the front cover, making sure the magnet is in the correct spot.

What we like

  • High quality
  • Scratch resistant

What we don’t like

  • Quality control lacking

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


3- Outus Magnetic Card Holder 35 Pt

The next magnetic card sleeve on our list is the Outus Magnetic Card Holder 35 Pt. Again, these are standard sized which is the perfect size for the majority of trading cards on the market. This brand is a little less known than BCW and Ultra PRO, but will still get the job done.

This set comes with 10 acrylic card protectors and comes at an incredible value compared to the other brands which are only providing 5 protectors. They are very durable and also contain U.V absorbers to help prevent ultraviolet light from yellowing your cards.

The magnet is at the top of the card sleeve making it easy to open and close. There is also card corner protection with grooves on all 4 of the corners to make sure your cards will not be bent.

What we like

  • Good quality
  • Great price

What we don’t like

  • Poor quality control

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


4- Pro-Mold 35pt. Magnetic One Touch Card Holders

The next sleeves on our list are the Pro-Mold 35pt. Magnetic One Touch Card Holders. Pro-Mold has been around awhile, but has recently started creating more and more products geared towards protecting you collection.

These 35 pt card holders come in a pack of 5, similar to the other brands listed previously. Perfect size for standard sized trading cards.

It’s a simplified two piece design with a gold magnet. This is the tried and true design of just about every magnetic card sleeve, and with good reason. Having it being only two pieces and having the magnet at the top allows you to easily place or remove cards in the card holder.

What we like

  • Good quality
  • Two piece design
  • Magnet at the top

What we don’t like

  • Quality control issues

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


5- X PRO 35PT Magnetic Card Holder 

The last magnetic card sleeve on our list is the X PRO 35PT Magnetic Card Holder. These standard sized card sleeves are great for almost any brand of trading card. These come in a pack of 15 at a decent competitive price. They offer both UV and corner protection which is a must have if you want your cards to be properly protected.

The magnetic closure is both durable and easy to use. Simply pop it open at the top with either a fingernail or a quarter, place your card inside, and then replace the front cover.

What we like

  • Good quality
  • Good price
  • UV and corner protection

What we don’t like

  • Quality control issues

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


What to Look for in a Magnetic Card Holder

To find the best Magnetic Card Holder for your needs, consider the following major aspects before finalizing a purchase.

Quantity

When purchasing any type of card sleeve or holder, it is important to know how many sleeves you will need. Most of the time you will be able to purchase card sleeves in bulk which in turn will result in lower cost.

Quality

Many of the top picks on our list are from well known and trusted brands that create high quality products. Some things to look out for is how well the cases withstand outside stressors such as sunlight and scratches.

High quality magnetic card sleeves will block UV light to help prevent yellowing. The corners will also have grooves to help prevent damage to the corners of your cards. Lastly, is scratch resistance. It’s imperative to choose a card sleeve that is less prone to scratching, especially if you plan on stacking your collection on top of each other.

Best Magnetic Card Holder Brands

Ultra PRO

If you don’t know Ultra PRO, you are either living under a rock, are you are brand new to collectible trading card games. Chances are that you have most likely seen Ultra PRO inside of your major national retail store along with tons of other hobby and toys stores all around the world.

Ultra PRO has been around since the early 1950’s and have definitely paved a name for themselves in the industry as the leader. They have been designing and manufacturing top quality products for collectible card games since the beginning and have only been improving and innovating over time.

All of their products are marketed and sold through a network of over 150 distributors all around the world. This includes North America, Europe, and even Asia.

BCW

BCW is another great established brand in the collectible trading card space. They offer tons of different products from card sleeves and binders, to deck boxes and storage boxes. At BCW, they are committed to providing the best customer service possible as that is their number one priority.

BCW was founded back in 1981 and has been manufacturing high quality products for over 35 years now. BCW has reached a milestone of serving over 100,000 customers on across all seven continents.

Pro-Mold

Pro-Mold has been around for quite some time as well, but only barely got their feet wet with collectible trading card products. Pro-Mold introduced their first product which was the Mini-Snap back in the early 90’s. This product was later patented under the U.S. This was the first hard plastic holder to fit in the standard storage box.

FAQs

What Is a Magnetic Card Holder?

A magnetic card holder is a card sleeve that is kept closed with the use of a magnet. These styles of card sleeves are usually hard in nature which make them great to use for valuable cards.

To use a magnetic card sleeve, you will need to use either a quarter or your fingernails to open the tab at the top of the card holder. These card sleeves are usually recessed and will have arrowed corners so nothing will be able to touch the corners of your card.

Are Magnetic Card Holders Good?

Magnetic card holders are very good at keeping your cards protected. Not only do magnetic card sleeves look great, but they also offer superior card protection due to their hard, plastic case.

These card sleeves are great as they can either be stored or set up for display for everyone to see your collection.

Final Thoughts

Our top pick for the best magnetic card sleeve is the Ultra Pro 35-Point ONE-Touch Magnetic Trading Card Holder. Ultra PRO has proven time and time again that they are the best in the industry when it comes to anything collectible card related. Their magnetic card holders are both high quality and very durable.

Our runner up is the BCW Magnetic Card Holder. BCW is a very close second as they also offer high quality products. BCW offers card sleeves at a slightly lower price, but in turn, they aren’t as good quality wise. They will scratch easier than the Ultra PRO brand, but if that’s not an issue for you, then these would also be a solid choice.

Whichever magnetic card holder you choose for your trading card collection, we hope this guide has been helpful in your purchasing decision. Thanks for reading!

Indoor Game Bunker

We are Indoor Game Bunker, a group dedicated to providing reviews, how to guides, and helpful information to those interested in a wide variety of games and hobbies.

Recent Posts