Top 5 Best Penny Sleeves for Magic Cards

best penny sleeves for magic cards

Sleeving your Magic the Gathering cards is a must, especially if you want them to keep them in tip top shape and condition. Not every deck or card requires a premium sleeve, which makes penny sleeves a great alternative due to their high quantity and low price.

Penny sleeves come in a wide variety of brands and sizes. Standard sized penny sleeves are the perfect size for Magic cards, however with all the different brands on the market it can be a hard to choose the best one. We sifted through the market and made a list of the highest quality penny sleeves available.

In our comprehensive guide to the best penny sleeves for magic cards, we’ll show you the best sleeves on the market for the money and give you some advice when it comes time to choose. Let’s get started.


NameOur RatingPrice
TitanShield Card Sleeves5/5
Click for Price
Ultra PRO Penny Sleeves4.5/5
Click for Price
Vault X Soft Trading Card Sleeves4/5
Click for Price

1- TitanShield Card Sleeves

The top pick on our list is the TitanShield card sleeves. This value pack comes crammed with 150 sleeves which means one pack should be able to sleeve most decks or games. A dual textured surface with anti-slip properties allow these to easily be handled allowing for great shuffle ability as well as superb protection for only being penny sleeves.

These sleeves are made out of polypropylene material and are acid free and non pvc. These sleeves of premium thickness and are 100 microns thick. This thickness is specifically designed for trading cards and board games alike.

What we like

  • Great price
  • High quality
  • Dual textured

What we don’t like

  • Will have to be replaced often

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

2- Ultra PRO Penny Sleeves

The next card sleeves up on our list is none other than, Ultra PRO penny sleeves. Ultra PRO has probably been around the longest out of all the brands, and deserve a top spot.

Not only does Ultra PRO strive to bring high quality products to the table, but they are the most easily available as they can be found in almost any retail or hobby card store. This bundle comes with 5 packs of 100 sleeves and are also able to fit into top loaded card holders.

These penny sleeves offer exceptional protection for single cards even though they are of a lower tier card sleeve.

What we like

  • High quality
  • 5 packs of 100
  • Low Price

What we don’t like

  • Loose/cheap feel

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

3- Vault X Soft Trading Card Sleeves

Next up on our list is Vault X. Vault X has been innovating the game with their unique and innovative products. Their penny sleeves prove to be just that. They are about 40 microns thick which is the perfect option for grading submissions as well as bulk storage. They are high quality, very clear, and made from archival-safe, acid-free non-PVC material.

If you are looking for a durable, thin sleeve at a great price, then these sleeves will get the job done. Their durability isn’t as good due to the lower thickness, but they are still perfect to put into card binders. These sleeves have also been designed to provide fast pack to sleeve protection for your trading cards, You can pair these with the Vault X rigid and semi-rigid card holders for awesome protection.

What we like

  • Low price
  • Good quality
  • Very clear

What we don’t like

  • Lower thickness

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

4- Pro Support Premium Ultra Clear Sleeves

Pro Support is another new player in the game of trading card accessories. At this time they only have a small selection, and that is limited just to card sleeves. Their penny sleeves come in a pack of 200 and are standard sized at 64mm x 89mm.

These sleeves are perfect for keeping your single cards protected and can be used as a single or double sleeve. They were specifically built for trading cards and board games alike. They are high quality, acid-free, and non PVC.

What we like

  • High quality
  • Great for double sleeving

What we don’t like

  • Pricey
  • Size may not be exact

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

5- Dragon Shield Arcane Tinman Clear Sleeves

Dragon Shield is one of the most well known brands in the trading card industry. Not only that, they are also probably the most popular when it comes to competitive gaming. Their lineup of premium card sleeves is bar none the best. They have tons of colors, and their quality is unrivaled. But what about their clear penny sleeves?

There are mixed reviews for these card sleeves. Although they are high quality, Non PVC, acid-free, and archival safe, their quality control for these sleeves is where they are lacking. There are tons of complaints that the sizes are incorrect.

If you can get past the fact that the quality control on these are not the greatest, you will still have some of the best penny sleeves on the market. They offer a clear front and back, are high quality, and have split resistant corners.

What we like

  • High quality
  • Split resistant
  • Clear front and back

What we don’t like

  • Inconsistent card sleeve sizes
  • Pricey

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

What to Look for in a Penny Sleeve

To find the best penny sleeve for your needs, consider the following major aspects before finalizing a purchase.


When purchasing penny sleeves, you will want to make sure that you get the correct size. You will need to make sure the card sleeves are at least of standard sized to fit Magic cards. Some trading card games, like Yugioh, have smaller cards. The japanese style card sleeves will be to small for Magic the Gathering cards.


We recommend only purchasing card sleeves that are high quality to prevent tearing. High quality penny sleeves will most likely be made out of a polypropylene material. They will also be acid free and non pvc.


Since penny sleeves are fairly cheap, they will come in large quantities. Always be sure to check the quantity before purchasing because you may be paying more or less for your sleeves depending on how many the packs come with.

Best Penny Sleeve Brands


TitanShield was started by a group of avid gamer. They realized there was a small gap in the market and that most of the trading card game supplies were expensive, unreliable, or both.

TitanShield is fairly new and started in 2017. Since then, they have been offering premium tabletop and trading card gaming accessories at very competitive prices.

They are able to price their products the way they do because they go straight to the supplier to get the best deals possible for their items. TitanShield has since been expanding on their catalogue bringing unique, innovative, and high quality items at the best prices possible.

Ultra PRO

Ultra PRO is probably the oldest leading manufacturer when it comes to supplies for gaming collectible accessories. They have been around since the 1950’s and are in just about every major retail store you walk into. Ultra PRO is a family owned company and has head offices near Los Angeles, CA.

Ultra PRO is mostly known for their famous high quality penny sleeves, as well as their card binders, binder pages, and more. Ultra PRO has over 120 distributors in North America, Europe and Asia which in turn supplies all the major retail stores, toy stores, and hobby stores worldwide.

Pro Support Accessories

Pro Support is a fairly new brand that has been slowly crawling up the ranks. As of right now, the only products they are selling is card sleeves, but in the future anything can change.

Pro Support strives when it comes to customer service and they try to make every person happy.


What Sleeves Fit Magic Cards?

Most standard sized penny sleeves should be able to fit your Magic the Gathering cards just fine. It is recommended to have sleeves that measure at least 63.5 x 88mm. Most standard sized sleeves will be slightly above this number.

The best fit for your Magic cards is a nice and snug fit. Having a sleeve that is too tight can end up damaging your card. Always be sure to use the correct sleeve size to avoid damage to your cards.

What Are the Best Sleeves for Magic?

When it comes to penny sleeves, we highly recommend the TitanShield brand. They are fairly new in the industry, but their quality is superb.

Many companies do not care to put much effort into their penny sleeves and use low quality materials for the biggest return on investment, but TitanShield made sure that they didn’t follow suit.

Final Thoughts

TitanShield penny sleeves are our top pick hands down. They offer the highest quality sleeves with the lowest price which makes them the best pick. Their sleeves also offer a dual textured surface for increased handling and shuffle ability which is very unique compared to the other brands.

The close runner up is none other than Ultra PRO. They have been around for decades and have some of the highest quality sleeves available on the market. These sleeves can be found at just about any major retail or hobby card store.

Whichever penny sleeves you choose for your Magic the Gathering cards, we hope this guide has been helpful in your purchasing decision. Thanks for reading!

Indoor Game Bunker

We are Indoor Game Bunker, a group dedicated to providing reviews, how to guides, and helpful information to those interested in a wide variety of games and hobbies.

Recent Posts