"IndoorGameBunker is supported by its readers. Please assume all links are affiliate links. If you purchase something from one of our links we make a small commission from Amazon."

Top 10 Best Magic the Gathering Booster Boxes to Make Money: Reviews and Complete Buying Guide

best magic the gathering booster boxes to make money

Opening a booster box of Magic the Gathering cards can be frustrating if you don’t pull any good cards worth your money, especially with the prices of trading cards these days. With so many different booster boxes on the market, it takes a lot of time and research to pinpoint which booster boxes have the most valuable cards in them.

We did the hard work for you and researched the top 10 booster boxes with some of the most expensive rare cards to get the most out of your return. Each set listed below will have a variety of valuable cards in them, some more than others. We chose to list the most valuable card for each set for your leisure from each booster box.

We left out old and vintage booster boxes on purpose due to the sheer fact that they are very expensive or are impossible to find due to rarity! All of our decisions were based on the current Magic the Gathering card prices which can be found here. Due to price fluctuations, we did not list the market value of each card as they can rise or fall at any time.

In our comprehensive guide to the best Magic the Gathering booster boxes, we’ll show you the best boosters on the market for the money and give you some advice when it comes time to choose. Let’s get started.

IN A HURRY? HERE’S OUR TOP PICKS…

NameOur RatingPrice

Commander Legends Collector Booster Box
5/5
Click for Price
Ultimate Masters Booster Box4.5/5
Click for Price
Time Spiral Remastered Draft Booster Box4/5
Click for Price

1- Commander Legends Collector Booster Box

Jeweled Lotus (Extended Art)

The first booster box that we are taking a look at is arguable the best booster box to buy, largely because it has a very rare card. The commander series is the first booster set designed specifically for the new Magic the Gathering format, Commander.

You will be searching for the Jeweled Lotus (Extended Art). At the time of writing this card is going for over 500$. However, this has also caused this booster box to be extremely expensive, but is well worth it if you were to pull this card out of the box as anything else you pull will purely be profit.

Not only does this set have Jeweled Lotus, but it also has 4 other great cards worth a good amount of money. Mana Drain (Extended Art), Vampiric Tutor (Extended Art), Jeweled Lotus, and Hullbreacher (Extended Art) are also great cards to chase as they are all worth over 100$-150$.

What we like

  • 12 collector booster packs
  • Mana Drain
  • Vampiric Tutor
  • Hullbreacher
  • Jeweled Lotus
  • 24+ foil etched cards
  • 60 legendary cards
  • 48+ rares

What we don’t like

  • Very high price point

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


2- Ultimate Masters Booster Box

Mana Vault (Foil)

The runner up booster pack on our top 10 list is Ultimate Masters. This set can even be a tie with the Commander Legends set as this set released a ton of powerful monsters from throughout the entire history of Magic the Gathering.

The big money card you will be looking to pull from this set is Mana Vault, and as we all know, anything that creates more mana than it costs to put into play is an awesome card. This card in foil form just makes it one very expensive and sought after card.

Some other noteworthy cards that are still worth a pretty penny are Liliana of the Veil, Cavern of Souls, Phyrexian Altar, Kozilek, Butcher of Truth, Ulamog, the Infinite Gyre, and a few other lower end, but still valuable, cards.

What we like

  • Mana Vault (Foil)
  • Liliana of the Veil
  • Phyrexian Altar
  • Ulamog, the Infinite Gyre
  • Kozilek, Butcher of Truth
  • 24 booster packs of 15 cards
  • 1 Ultimate Box Topper pack

What we don’t like

  • Very high price point
  • Small number of valuable cards, increasing risk vs reward

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


3- Time Spiral Remastered Draft Booster Box

Thoughtseize (Foil)

Time Spiral Remastered is the next booster box on this list, and is probably the best booster box to buy to diversify your risk as it has quite a few cards that are worth over 150$ each.

The main money card you will be seeking from this set is Thoughtseize. As an extremely powerful unconditional discard card, it remains very valuable in todays meta.

Other noteworthy cards to keep an eye out for are Ponder, Yawgmoth, Thran Physician, Chalice of the Void, Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker, Abrupt Decay, True-Name Nemesis, and Leyline of the Void.

What we like

  • Lots of valuable cards to diversify risk
  • Ponder
  • Yawgmoth, Thran Physician
  • Chalice of the Void
  • Kiki-Jiki
  • Mirror Breaker
  • Abrput Decay
  • True-Name Nemesis
  • Leyline of the Void
  • 36 Time Spiral Remastered draft booster packs with 15 cards per pack
  • 1 card with a retro Magic frame in every pack

What we don’t like

  • High price point

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


4- Modern Horizons Booster Box

Force of Negation (Foil)

The Modern Horizons booster box is number 4, but don’t think that it’s still not worthy of your time and investment.

The big hitter in this set is Force of Negation. It’s a very powerful card to have in combo deck and is also the most powerful force in the cycle.

Other great cards to pull in this set are Wrenn and Six, Urza, Lord High Artificer, Prismatic Vista, The First Sliver, and Echo of Eons.

What we like

  • Force of Negation is a very valuable card
  • Set is designed specifically for the modern format
  • 540 total cards per booster box
  • Wrenn and Six
  • Lord High Artificer
  • Prismatic Vista
  • The First Silver
  • Echo of Eons

What we don’t like

  • High price point

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


5- Double Masters Draft Booster Box

Force of Will (Foil)

Next we have the Double Masters Booster box. This is an interesting booster box as it has some of Magic’s most powerful cards ever created.

The money card you are hunting for in this set is Force of Will (Borderless). Force of will is a great card because it can be used to bait your opponent to unleash their combo on you when you are tapped out.

Other great cards to pull from Double Masters is Mana Crypt (Borderless), Mana Crypt, Force of Will, Sword of Feast and Famine (Borderless), Doubling Season (Borderless), and Jace, the Mind Sculptor (Borderless).

What we like

  • Great variety of valuable cards in the 100$-300$ range which diversifies risk
  • Force of Will (Borderless)
  • Two rares, two foils per pack
  • Two box toppers ber box
  • 24 booster packs

What we don’t like

  • Very high price point

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


6- Throne of Eldraine Booster Box

The Great Henge (Extended Art)

The next box on our list is the Throne of Eldraine booster box. It comes with 36 packs of 15 cards.

The heavy hitter card in this set is The Great Henge (Extended Art). The Great Henge is just an overall awesome card for any green deck and is a must have if you want to play one.

Some other lower end, but still valuable cards are Oko, Thief of Crowns (Borderless), Questing Beast (Extended Art), Rankle, Master of Pranks (Extended Art), and Embercleave (Extended Art).

What we like

  • Decent price point
  • The Great Henge
  • 36 booster packs, 15 cards per pack

What we don’t like

  • Not many valuable cards to diversify risk

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


7- Kaldheim Collector Booster Box

Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider (Phyrexian)

The next booster box on our list is Kaldheim Collector Booster Box. It comes with 15 cards with 1 foil token per pack and comes with 12 collector booster packs overall.

The money card in this set is Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider (Phyrexian). This variant is specifically worth much more money due to the sheer fact that it’s just awesome.

Other noteworthy cards include Valki, God of Lies // Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor (Showcase), Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider (Showcase), and Valki, God of Lies // Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor (Borderless).

What we like

  • Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider (Phyrexian)

What we don’t like

  • High price point
  • Only a few valuable cards worth pulling

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


8- Theros Beyond Death Booster Box

Uro, Titann of Nature’s Wrath

Nearing the end of our top 10 list is the Theros Beyond Death booster box. This underworld themed set contains a few valuable cards.

Uro, Titan of Nature’s Wrath (Extended Art) is the shing star in this set. It’s a great card due to the fact that It draws card, ramps, and gains life and does so repeatedly.

A few other cards worth pulling are Kroxa, Titan of Death’s Hunger (Extended Art), Nyxbloom Ancient (Extended Art), and Dryad of the Ilysian Grove (Extended Art).

What we like

  • Decent price point
  • Diversified risk as all cards are similar value

What we don’t like

  • Only a few cards worth pulling

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


9- Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Draft Booster Box

Illuna, Apex of Wishes (Promo)

The Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Draft Booster Box is number 9 on our list. It comes with 36 booster packs and each sealed Draft Booster Box comes with 1 of 15 possible foil Godzilla Series Monsters.Lurrus of the Dream-Den (Extended Art), and Winota, Joiner of Forces (Extended Art).

You will be looking to pull Illuna, Apex of Wishes (Promo). It’s a sought after card, and is worth even more in it’s Promo form.

Other mentionable cards are Luminous Broodmoth (Promo),

What we like

  • Diversified Risk
  • Decent price point

What we don’t like

  • Lower valuable cards

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


10- Zendikar Rising Collector Booster Box

Cavern of Souls (Foil)

The Zendikar Rising Collector Booster Box concludes our top 10 list of booster boxes to buy to make money. The set includes 12 booster packs and at least 11 foils.

You’ll be trying to pull Cavern of Souls in this set. This card is valuable due to the modern format.

What we like

  • 12 packs and two toppers

What we don’t like

  • Lower amount of valuable cards
  • High Price point

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon


What to Look for in a Magic the Gathering Booster Box if You Want to Make Money

To find the best Magic the Gathering Booster box for your needs, consider the following major aspects before finalizing a purchase.

Price Per Booster Box

Since most of these booster boxes are from previous sets, they can get very pricey due to rarity. Prices can fluctuate on a weekly basis, as well as day to day depending on the amount of booster boxes in stock at the current time of checking.

When looking to maximize your capital gain when buying MTG booster boxes, be sure to always check current card prices of the set you are looking at to see if it’s something you want to invest in.

Amount of Rare and Valuable Cards in the Set

Every set will have a different number of rare and valuable cards. If you are feeling lucky, then purchasing the booster boxes with the most valuable cards will yield the greatest returns if they are pulled, but with added risk.

To diversify risk, it would be best to purchase a booster pack with a wide variety of mid-tier cards that are lower value, but give you a better chance of pulling them since their are more to pull in a set.

Best Magic the Gathering Booster Box Brands

MAGIC: THE GATHERING – Wizards of the Coast

Wizards of the coast has been around since Dungeons and Dragons. They have a huge family of studios and they specialize in building trading card games, role playing games, and Massively Multiplayer Online games for all genres of players.

FAQs

What Is the Best MTG Booster Box to Buy?

The best booster box to buy is the Commander Legends Collector Booster Box. It has the Jeweled Lotus card that is worth over 500$ if pulled.

Are MTG Booster Boxes Worth It?

MTG booster boxes are definitely worth buying. It’s always important to do your due diligence first to make sure you are not overpaying drastically for a box that can otherwise be found cheaper elsewhere.

Another great investment strategy is to buy current booster boxes, which aren’t as price spiked, to hold onto and sell at a later date if you don’t want to take the risk of opening them for the rare cards yourself.

Is Modern Horizons Booster Box Worth It?

Modern Horizons is a good booster box to purchase. It has 3 cards that are worth over 100$ each if pulled. The main card you would be trying to chase in this set is Force of Negation.

Are Set Boosters Worth It?

Set boosters are a great way to complete a set as they offer a wider variety of more rare and valuable cards to be pulled than a draft booster or collector booster.

Final Thoughts

Always remember that prices are not static, but dynamic. Prices can change on a weekly or monthly basis due to shift in the current meta game and card scarcity. Please check card prices here to make sure you are investing in profitable boxes based on their current card values and booster box price.

Out of all the booster boxes, we recommend Commander Legends, Ultimate Masters, and Time Spiral Remastered as these boxes offer the most valuable cards to pull. However, if you are looking to diversify your risk with more valuable card choices, then we recommend purchasing booster packs farther down in our list.

Whichever Magic the Gathering booster pack box you choose, we hope this guide has been helpful in your purchasing decision. Thanks for reading!

Indoor Game Bunker

We are Indoor Game Bunker, a group dedicated to providing reviews, how to guides, and helpful information to those interested in a wide variety of games and hobbies.

Recent Posts