Top 5 Best Storage Cases for Graded Cards

Best Storage Cases for Graded Cards

Having a high-quality storage case for your graded cards is one of the best ways to protect them even further, especially if you have a large amount in your collection.

With all the different storage cases on the market, it can be hard to choose the best one for your graded cards. The main differentiating factors between cases are the storage capacity, as well as how well they will store and protect your slabbed cards.

In our comprehensive guide to the best storage cases for graded cards, we’ll show you the best cases on the market and give you some advice when it comes time to choose. Let’s get started.


NameOur RatingPrice

PREZA Graded Card Storage Box
Click for Price
CASEMATIX Graded Card Case4.5/5
Click for Price
2TUFF Graded Sports Card Case4/5
Click for Price

1- PREZA Graded Card Storage Box

The first storage case on our list is the PREZA Graded Card Storage Box. This is our top pick when it comes to storing graded cards. This storage case offers premium storage space. Each of these trading card cases can hold an astonishing 108 graded PSA cards, or 78 BGS-graded cards. If you will be using this case for toploaders, then you can fit up to about 370 of them in this case.

At first glance, this case looks awesome. It comes in black color with a matte/satin style finish which really makes it pop. The outside hardware on the case is also color matched with the case to give it a nice high-quality and sleek design.

One of the best features of this storage case is that it comes with a lock and 2 spare keys. A lock and key feature are very important if you want to keep your collection protected and secure.

We can’t forget about one of the most important parts of the case, which is the inside. On the inside, there are 3 foam inserts that help to create a secure and snug fit for all of your graded cards.

What we like

  • Lock and key
  • Holds a lot of cards
  • Universal fit design
  • Carry handle
  • Foam inserts for protection

What we don’t like

  • Expensive

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

2- CASEMATIX Graded Card Case

The next storage case on our list is the CASEMATIX Graded Card Case. This is another high-quality storage case that is perfect for storing graded cards.

At first glance, the outside of this case looks kind of like a toolbox, but don’t let that deter you from choosing this case. However, it doesn’t only offer looks. The CASEMATIX case offers a crushproof case that has a hard shell exterior to prevent your cards from being crushed or damaged.

The CASEMATIX case is also waterproof due to it having O-rings and an airtight design. This helps to lock out all air and moisture for a truly protective case. This will help to prevent any type of water damage to your cards from accidental spills or bad weather.

The inside offers two custom storage box foam slots for you to place your cards into. The two impact-absorbing slots are designed to store your cards vertically. They can fit up to 40+ PSA cards, up to 30 BGS cards, and 70+ toploader cards.

For security purposes, there is a pair of padlock rings molded directly onto the shell on both sides. Unfortunately, it does not come with padlocks which means you will need to purchase them separately for added security.

What we like

  • Good price
  • Foam inserts for protection
  • Decent card capacity
  • Carry handle

What we don’t like

  • Does not include padlocks or keys

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

3- 2TUFF Graded Card One-Touch and Screwdown Sports Card Case

Next on our list is the 2TUFF Graded Card One-Touch and Screwdown Sports Card Case. This case is versatile and is able to fit a wide variety of different cards ranging from football, baseball, hockey, and even non-sports cards. In order to place slabbed cards into this case, simply remove the inner foam piece from the lid.

On the inside, there are 4 slots that measure about 9.5 inches long by 3.2 inches wide. Each section is also about 4 inches deep as well. For added protection, the inside is lined with velvet to keep the plastic cases from getting scratched and moving around freely.

On the outside of the storage case is a built-in lock with a key for added protection and security. These locks are attached to heavy-duty latches which work together to keep your case locked and secured.

This case is able to hold a total of 168 PSA slabs, and up to 520 toploaders.

What we like

  • High quality
  • Low price
  • Lots of storage space

What we don’t like

  • Quality control issues

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

4- Card Titan Pro Graded Card Storage Box

The next storage case on our list is the Card Titan Pro Graded Card Storage Box. This is another high-quality case, however, it does have a smaller storage capacity compared to the other cases that we looked at. This storage case is able to hold up to 36 PSA-graded cards in total.

The inside is constructed and designed with a high-quality textured EVA with foam interior sections to help protect and secure your cards. Each row has a separate slot so your slabs will not be touching each other which helps keep your cards from becoming scratched.

The outside of the case features a built-in combination lock that secures the zippers shut. This style of protection isn’t as durable or as strong as latches but still does a good job.

What we like

  • Good price
  • Combination lock with zipper
  • High quality

What we don’t like

  • Not much storage space

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

5- Boobowl Graded Card Storage Box

The last storage case on our list is the Boobowl Graded Card Storage Box. At first glance, this storage case looks like a suitcase and is very similar to that. Don’t let its looks fool you, it is still great for storing your collectible cards in slabs as well as toploaders.

The total card capacity with the foam inserts is 66 graded sports trading cards. The inside of this storage case can be modified to fit a variety of accessories like deck boxes, card sleeves, and even toploaders.

The outside of the storage case is made out of a premium EVA material that is both waterproof and shock resistant. This provides your cards with superior protection against scratches, dust, and damage. The lightweight case is very durable, and comes with a handle as well as an adjustable shoulder strap for easy carrying.

What we like

  • Well priced
  • High quality
  • Waterproof and shock resistant

What we don’t like

  • Does not have the best card fitment

Check Price and Reviews on Amazon

What to Look for in a Storage Case

To find the best Storage Case for your needs, consider the following major aspects before finalizing a purchase.

Card Capacity

One of the first things to look for in a storage case is the card capacity. Each storage box will have a different card capacity, and many of the will list the type of holder and the amount it will fit.

Most cases are universal and will be able to hold different styles of card sleeves like BGS, PSA, and generic toploaders.


Security is definitely something you will want to have when it comes to a storage box for graded cards. Graded cards are very valuable, so having a storage case with some type of lock and key is recommended to keep your collection safe and protected.

Card Fitment

Many of the best storage cases will have foam inserts inside in order to give your cards a snug fit. Most of the time, these foam inserts will be customizable which means you will be able to move them around to suit your specific needs.

Best Storage Case Brands


Ever since CaseMatix was created, back in 2014, they have been focusing on one thing. They wanted to make the best travel cases for a variety of hobbies including video games, trading cards, and more.

They were founded as a case industry hub for only the best and more high-quality protection for your products. Their items offer both security and quality at affordable prices. They offer a wide variety of cases for many different products, which means you will most likely be able to find a case within your budget.

CaseMatix is responsible for developing hundreds of best-selling items across many eCommerce platforms, including Amazon.


How Do You Store a Graded Card?

Graded cards can be stored in storage cases designed specifically for graded cards. Graded cards take up a lot of space due to their plastic slabs.

Storing a graded card is as simple as placing the card vertically or horizontally into the storage case, depending on the design of the case.

Related: Sports Card Value Scanner App

Final Thoughts

Our top pick is the PREZA Graded Card Storage Box. This storage case is all around as perfect as it gets, from its hard shell exterior to the protective foam inserts on the inside. This case even comes with a padlock and 2 keys for added security and protection.

The next case on our list is the CASEMATIX Graded Card Case. This is another great case to use for your graded cards, especially if you want to spend a lot less. Although this case holds quite a bit less, it still offers great protection and security features. With a crushproof outside and airtight, waterproof inside, this case is great at doing what it was designed to do.

Whichever storage case you choose for your graded cards, we hope this guide has been helpful in your purchasing decision. Thanks for reading!

Indoor Game Bunker

We are Indoor Game Bunker, a group dedicated to providing reviews, how to guides, and helpful information to those interested in a wide variety of games and hobbies.

Recent Posts