Do Card Shops Grade Cards? Yes, But The Value will be Unofficial

Do Card Shops Grade Cards

In many cases, cards that have been professionally graded command a lot more cash on the secondary market. Therefore, if you end up in possession of a particularly rare card, you may wonder how you can go about having it graded. In fact, you may even wonder whether it is going to be worth grading. 

So, do card shops grade cards? The answer is no. Well, they may grade cards, but you will not be able to use their card grade as an ‘official grade’ if you want to sell. Card shops do not have the experience or reputation for this. This means if you want a properly graded card, you will need to send it away.

Let’s go into a bit more depth on this. This way, you will know exactly what you can expect regarding trading card grading. 

How Much Does It Cost to Get a Card Graded?

There are a lot of factors at play here. This means that while we wish we could give you a proper value for the card grading process, this is impossible. The cost could be anywhere from $20 to $200+. Let us explain why.

Related: Where to Get Cards Graded in Person? Here Are Your Options

The Card Grading Company Used

This will be one of the biggest factors regarding the cost of card grading.

Companies like PSA know that when people buy trading cards, they will look out for PSA-graded cards. This is because PSA is incredibly strict with its grading. They know that if PSA rated a card an 8, that is a fantastic score. A card that HGA has graded is worth a whole lot less.

If you are getting your cards graded, it is worth working with companies like PSA. It costs a little bit more, though.

The Turnaround Time for Card Grading

Some companies offer a turnaround time for grading. Even in the fastest cases, it may still take a month for them to get to your card. In 2021, many companies shut down the slow grading processes. This is because they are dealing with vast backlogs of cards that could take several months to get through.

The Value of the Card

This doesn’t apply to all card graders. However, some places charge more to handle the most valuable of cards, mainly if they are worth more than a few thousand dollars.

This is (mostly) to cover the extra costs of insurance on the card. However, it is also because they know their grading could increase the card’s value even further.

Is It Worth Getting Cards Graded?

To be honest with you, most cards are not worth getting graded. In fact, there are only a few situations where we believe it may be worth getting your card graded.

The Card Is Very Rare

If the trading card is incredibly rare, it may be worth getting it graded. For example, if you had a Charizard from the base set of Pokemon in a fairly decent condition, it may be worth getting that card graded. This is because there are not many of them around. When you get the card graded, you protect it from any damage.

The older a card is, the rarer it becomes. Although, we certainly wouldn’t classify the card’s rarity as the only deciding factor for getting a card graded. It needs a value, which leads us to the next reason you may want to consider when determining whether it is worth getting your card graded.

The Card Has Value

The card needs to have value. As you can see from before, the cost of getting cards graded can be on the high side.

We wouldn’t recommend getting a card graded if it has a value of under $100 on the secondary market. This is because there isn’t really any money to be made by the time you have got the card graded. 

Remember, you need to consider the collector’s value of the card here, not the value in playability. For example, many Magic the Gathering cards are worth over $100. However, these cards only have that value because of their value when building decks. If you get them graded, they become useless, and their value will plummet.

If you want a decent idea of the potential value of a trading card, then it may be worth going through various sites (including eBay) which focus on the secondary trading card market. This should tell you the price difference between graded cards and ungraded cards.

We wouldn’t recommend that you get graded trading cards unless you understand the game. Things become a lot more difficult when you want to determine whether a card is valuable because it is played or because it is rare.

You Really Love the Card

For some, the value of a card is emotional. You don’t have any intentions of selling it. It is just one of your favorite cards. In this case, you may want to pay to have it graded so you can preserve it forever. Grading will be a financial hit, but it may be worth it.

Best Companies to Have Your Cards Graded By


For the most part, you should always try to have your cards graded by PSA. This will be one of the business’s most respected card grading companies.


You can also have your cards graded by Beckett, sometimes called BGS. While there are other card grading companies, none of them will add value to your card in the same way as these two companies.

Can You Grade Your Own Cards?

No. If you do not have an official grade for your company, the card does not have a graded value. While you could look at the card and guess the potential value, we bet that not all that many people out there would care what you graded the card at.

Why Is Card Grading So Expensive?

It takes an astonishing amount of time and effort to grade a card. Card grading also requires a lot of experience. When you get a card graded, you are essentially paying for a good chunk of time from the card grader. Of course, insurance is also included in the cost.

These companies know that their card grades will also add value to your cards too. This means that they can charge a little bit more knowing that you will be earning from their expertise.

Final Thoughts

Card shops do not grade cards. They may offer a rough estimate on the grade of your card, but they will not be able to grade it officially.

If you want your card graded properly, you must go to either PSA or BGS. These are the best card grading companies around.

Remember, the cost of card grading can be high. This means that, in some cases, it may not even be worth the grading costs. 

Indoor Game Bunker

We are Indoor Game Bunker, a group dedicated to providing reviews, how to guides, and helpful information to those interested in a wide variety of games and hobbies.

Recent Posts